We DISAGREE | Can Halloween be Catholic Again?
Formed
•
26-Oct-2026
In costume, Taylor Kemp and Dr. Scott Hefelfinger take on Halloween: childhood memories, how their families approach it, and where the holiday comes from. They talk about how the Church took up older harvest-season customs into All Hallows’ Eve, All Saints, and All Souls, and why today’s secular Halloween shows a deep human longing around death. They also ask how Catholics should think about horror movies.
Scott’s tip is to treat All Saints’ Day as the center of the three feasts and explain the reason for the season to your kids. For more, see “Eternal Rest: The Art of Dying Well” and the What Catholics Believe episode on Halloween, both on Formed.
Have a question or topic idea for future episodes? Submit them here: http://practicingcatholicpodcast.com/
Up Next in Formed
-
What Catholics Believe About Hallowee...
Is Halloween really a pagan holiday—or is it deeply Christian? In this episode of What Catholics Believe, Dr. Ben Akers explains the Catholic roots of Halloween, its connection to All Saints’ Day and All Souls’ Day, and how Catholics can celebrate it faithfully. Discover the history of trick-or-t...